Today’s provocative “Hot Talk” radio commentators are not a new phenomenon. The first decade of broadcasting witnessed the rise of many equally strident and controversial personalities who tested the limits of the government’s tolerance and the public’s good taste. They were the prototypes of today’s conservative radio commentators and talk show hosts.
While early radio was endowed with many colorful but otherwise harmless characters, a handful of crusading firebrands used the airwaves to gain favor with the public for their viewpoints. The early airwaves were also home to a number of hucksters, like the infamous Kansas goat gland doctor John R. Brinkley. But radio also hosted a number of other troublemakers and agitators who abused the power of the media to try and influence public opinion. Let’s take a look at some of radio’s less-remembered provocateurs.
THE “OREGON WILDCAT,” KVEP
Soon after the 1929 stock market crash, Robert Gordon Duncan acquired a small station — KVEP, the “Voice of East Portland” in Oregon — from its financially distressed owner.
A populist firebrand vying for the Republican nomination to Congress, Duncan used his station to broadcast daily profanity-laced tirades. Calling himself the “Oregon Wildcat,” he reportedly kept a gun at his side while on the air. He railed against Sears & Roebuck and the other “chain stores” that were running local mom-and-pop retailers out of business. To bolster his cause, Duncan sought “donations” from small retailers, and lambasted those who rebuffed him for selling poor quality merchandise and cheating their customers.
After losing the Republican primary to the incumbent, Frank Korell, Duncan attacked the congressman on the air, questioning his sexual orientation. If these actions weren’t disruptive enough, Duncan also refused to sign off KVEP so that the station with which he shared his 1500 kHz frequency could broadcast.
Letters of complaint about KVEP flooded into the Federal Radio Commission, and a license renewal hearing was scheduled. Representatives of the American Legion, the Chamber of Commerce, local churches and other civic organizations joined forces at the hearing to demand cancellation of KVEP’s license.
Portland judge J.C. Kendall complained, “There is a mad dog loose in the city of Portland. For two hours every night, we have had a persistent series of talks so utterly indecent that they offend every human sensibility.”
On May 30, 1930, the commission ordered KVEP off the air because of “profanity, obscenity and the vilification of particular individuals.” The coup de grâce came in July, when Duncan’s creditors repossessed the station’s equipment. If that wasn’t enough, he was arrested and convicted of indecent broadcasting, violating the Radio Act of 1927. He was sentenced to six months in the county jail and fined $500.
After an unsuccessful attempt to launch a magazine, Duncan ended up managing a golf course and died in 1944.
GERALD BUCKLEY, WMBC
Jerry Buckley was one of early radio’s “good guys.” The popular radio commentator on WMBC in Detroit began his career as a radio crusader in 1928, campaigning for humanitarian and liberal causes like old-age pensions and jobs for the unemployed. He referred to the followers of his nightly program as “the Common Herd.”
In 1930, Buckley began a campaign against rampant corruption in the Detroit city government, emphasizing the ties between Mayor Charles Bowles and the city’s numerous gambling houses being run by organized crime. Buckley claimed that Bowles took his orders from Public Works Commissioner Joseph Gillespie, who was the “true mayor of Detroit.”
After Police Commissioner Harold Emmons raided the gambling houses while Bowles was out of town, the mayor fired him and appointed Thomas Wilcox, a supporter of Bowles’ “hands-off” policies. Buckley’s nightly tirades criticized Bowles, Gillespie and Wilcox, and decried the unlawful graft taking place behind the scenes. Buckley’s program soon became Detroit’s most popular show.
In 1930, Buckley began to campaign for a recall election to remove Mayor Bowles from office. As support for the idea grew, Buckley was offered a $25,000 bribe to “lay off” the mayor, which only caused him to double his efforts. Ultimately, a special election was scheduled for July 22. Buckley urged his audience to vote “yes,” and when the ballots in the bitterly-fought election were counted, Bowles was removed from office — 120,863 to 89,907 votes.
Two hours after the recall results were announced, Buckley got a phone call from a woman who promised a tip on a new story. She asked to meet him in the lobby of the LaSalle Hotel, where the WMBC studios were located. About 1:50 a.m., as Buckley waited in the lobby, three men entered the hotel and pumped 11 bullets into his body.
As the investigation into his murder mounted, Commissioner Wilcox attempted to smear Buckley’s reputation with an affidavit claiming he was paid $4,000 in “protection money” by a bootlegger, but the affidavit was quickly discredited as being coerced. Ultimately, several members of the notorious Licavoli Gang were arrested, but a conviction for Buckley’s murder was never obtained.
A crowd of over 50,000 attended his funeral on a rainy July afternoon — mostly faithful members of his “Common Herd” audience.
One listener commented, “These days, I hardly know how to act when 6 o’clock comes. I feel as if I had lost a loving friend. Jerry Buckley was the only man in Detroit who was so strong for the common people. Will these people forget him? They will not.”
FATHER COUGHLIN, WJR & CBS
Father Charles Edward Coughlin, the crusading radio commentator of the 1930s, was the forerunner of Rush Limbaugh and other modern talk radio hosts. The controversial Catholic priest burned up the airwaves from 1926 until he was forced off the air in 1939.
Pastor of the Shrine of the Little Flower church in Royal Oak, Mich., he began his radio career as a radio preacher on George A. Richards’ station WJR in Detroit, and in 1930 gained a national audience when his program was heard on CBS.
Encouraged by the politically conservative and anti-Semitic Richards, his topics soon changed from religion to politics, becoming increasingly inflammatory. At first, Coughlin took aim at communism and the KKK, but his attacks soon expanded to include mainstream targets like the banking industry and Jews.
When CBS required Coughlin to submit his scripts in advance for network approval, Coughlin refused and the network cancelled his program. But, backed by Richards, Coughlin established his own 36-station hookup for his “Golden Hour of the Shrine of the Little Flower” program, with WJR as the key station. Soon, Coughlin had a weekly audience estimated between 16 million and 30 million listeners. By 1934, he had to build his own post office to handle the 10,000 letters he received daily.
On the air, Coughlin faulted greedy bankers for causing the Depression and pleaded for Roosevelt to nationalize the Federal Reserve Bank and reform the monetary system. When FDR ignored his advice, Coughlin became one of his harshest critics, denouncing him as a “tool of Wall Street.” In 1934, he created the “National Union for Social Justice,” a nationalistic workers’ rights organization, and in 1936 he backed an unsuccessful fringe presidential candidate.
In one of his broadcasts, he stated, “I have dedicated my life to fight against the heinous rottenness of modern capitalism because it robs the laborer of this world’s goods. But, blow for blow, I shall strike against Communism, because it robs us of the next world’s happiness.”
In the later 1930s, Coughlin increasingly targeted Jews while praising Hilter and Mussolini. After one particularly inflammatory and inciting 1938 speech, a number of stations dropped his program, which incensed his faithful followers.
At WMCA in New York and WDAS in Pittsburgh, crowds of Coughlin’s fans protested outside the studios, yelling anti-semitic statements, like “Send Jews back where they came from in leaky boats!” and “Wait until Hitler comes over here!” It was later documented that Coughlin was receiving funding from Nazi Germany.
Numerous political organizations petitioned the FCC to remove Coughlin from the airwaves, but ultimately, it was the National Association of Broadcasters that forced him off the air. In October of 1939, the NAB adopted a new industry self-regulation code that prohibited its stations from discussing controversial issues in sponsored programs. The clause was specifically written to stop Coughlin.
Some NAB member stations, including WJR, WGAR and the Yankee Network, threatened to quit the association instead of observe the code, but when Coughlin’s contracts expired at the end of the month, most of his stations did not renew.
Although Coughlin continued crusading for fascism through his “Social Justice” newsletter, his influence was clearly diminished. Once World War II began, he was all but forgotten. Coughlin continued as a parish priest until his retirement in 1966. He died in Michigan in 1979 at the age of 88.
“FIGHTING BOB” SHULER, KGEF
Robert P. Shuler was another demagogue preacher, broadcasting from the Trinity Methodist Church in Los Angeles over his station KGEF starting in 1926.
At various times, his controversial broadcasts denounced Catholics, Jews, blacks, politicians, the police and dozens of other targets. He defended the Ku Klux Klan; he condemned the University of Southern California for permitting evolution to be taught on campus; he claimed that Catholics were “plotting to murder Protestants in their beds;” he attacked the public library for lending books “not fit to be read in heathen China or anarchist Russia;” he railed against the YMCA for permitting dances for girls that lasted until early hours of the morning. He announced that he had damaging personal information about certain individuals, but promised to not reveal it if they would send “donations” to KGEF.
The Los Angeles Times wrote that “‘Fighting Bob’ operates the most controversial religious radio station of all time. Politicians fear him, criminals avoid him, newspapers deplore him, and many ministers criticize him.”
Like Buckley in Detroit, Shuler attacked the considerable corruption of the city government and its cooperation with underworld figures. In 1929, Shuler’s attacks against Los Angeles Mayor George E. Cryer prompted a libel suit. But after a highly contentious and well-publicized trial, a jury found Shuler not guilty on one count and could not reach a verdict on the second count.
In 1931, Hearst’s Los Angeles Examiner and others petitioned the Federal Radio Commission to revoke KGEF’s license. In November, the commissioners voted to not renew the license, due to the character of Shuler’s broadcasts and his use of the station for personal attacks. KGEF was just the second station to have its license revoked for cause — the first being “Doc” Brinkley’s KFKB in Milford, Kan.
Shuler appealed the decision based on his station’s property rights and the right of free speech, but the D.C. Appeals Court upheld the FRC’s action in 1932. The court wrote that Shuler’s broadcasts were “sensational rather than instructive,” and that, if the airwaves could be used for such purposes, “radio will become a scourge and the nation a theater for the display of individual passions and the collision of personal interests.” A further appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court was rejected in 1933.
After two unsuccessful runs for political office, Shuler again began to broadcast his tirades in 1943 over KPAS in Pasadena, Calif. But no sooner had the broadcasts begun, than the FCC, declaring that his programs were hurting the war effort, directed the station to submit transcripts of Shuler’s broadcasts, and he was forced off the air for the last time. Shuler retired as the pastor of his church in 1953 and died in 1965.
“ol’ man” HENDERSON, KWKH
William K. Henderson was the wealthy owner of the Henderson Iron Works and Supply Company in Shreveport, La. Developing an early interest in radio broadcasting, he acquired part-interest in local station WGAQ in 1922, and then bought out his partners in 1925. Incorporating his initials, he renamed the station KWKH and installed a powerful 10,000 watt transmitter on the grounds of his estate, “Kennonwood.”
Blessed with high power and a clear channel and broadcasting only at night, KWKH’s signal blanketed the country. Henderson was the station’s only disc jockey, interspersing recorded music with his folksy commentary. He opened each broadcast with the chiming of a clock and his catch-phrase “Hello World!” He alternately referred to himself as “Doggone” Henderson, “Ol’ Man” Henderson and “Hello World” Henderson.
Before long, his rustic chats increasingly turned into commentaries on social and government issues. He castigated the Federal Radio Commission for favoring the assignment of frequencies to the big chain stations instead of independent local stations. He denounced the commissioners as “crooks, skunks and grafters.” Like Duncan, he mounted a spirited campaign against the “chain stores” for running small retailers out of business, and for the “ruinous and devastating effect of sending the profits out of our local communities to a common center, Wall Street.”
Henderson’s tremendous popularity hinged in part on his penchant for insulting his listeners. They would taunt him in telegrams, and he would fire back at them over the air in his coarse “country boy” language.
“People don’t care about gentle modest talk,” Henderson said. “They want it strong. They want to hear you ride somebody. If not, why do they spend their good money for telegrams? They want to be entertained. They razz me and wait for me to bawl them out over the radio. I never disappoint them if they sign their names.”
People tuned in because they never knew what he was going to say next. He developed such a following by 1928 that “Radio Digest” magazine named KWHK the South’s most popular station.
Not surprisingly, Henderson’s mixture of political diatribes and personal insults resulted in a flood of complaints to the Federal Radio Commission. One listener complained, “I listened for about three hours to a tirade of billingsgate, semi-profanity and vulgar abuse from the man who does most of the talking or announcing from this station. I had listened to this man’s peculiar, characteristic utterances several times before, but this night, as near as I could judge, he was drunk and repeated his abusive remarks over and over again. I listened in for the purpose of seeing how long he would keep up this disgusting sort of thing and to the best of my recollection it was almost three hours.”
The Radio Commission began monitoring Henderson’s broadcasts and sent agents to Shreveport to record KWKH, but it took no action against the renegade broadcaster.
Henderson’s ability to fend off the authorities was due to his friendship with Louisiana Governor Huey Long. Henderson contributed $10,000 to Long’s 1928 campaign and afforded him liberal amounts of free air time on his station. In turn, Long warned the FRC that he wouldn’t tolerate any sanctions against KWKH: “You’re going to have to fight Louisiana and other states too, buddy, and you won’t get away with it. We are going to expose you and not allow you to steal the air.” He assured Henderson that the Louisiana State Militia was at his disposal to protect KWKH against any threatened federal intervention.
Long successfully kept the FRC agents at bay until 1931, when a disagreement soured his relationship with Henderson. Now armed with recordings of his transmissions of “vile filth and profanity,” and evidence that the station was exceeding its authorized transmitter power, The FRC called Henderson to Washington to argue why his license should be revoked.
In 1932, after a series of lengthy hearings that also exposed some financial improprieties with listener, his lawyers informed him that his chances of keeping his station license were nil. By now nearly bankrupt, Henderson sold KWKH for $50,000 to a group of Shreveport businessmen, who moved the station back to town and affiliated it with the CBS network. KWKH had become a domesticated station and Henderson’s radio voice was silenced. His threats to start a Mexican “border blaster” station never came to fruition.
No off-air recordings are known to exist of W.K. Henderson, but there is a surviving phonograph recording that he distributed in 1930 that allows us to hear his Southern drawl and his tirades against the big broadcasting stations.
Listen to it at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wP_8acCbpkA.
By the mid-1930s, radio broadcasting had matured into a mainstream commercial industry, and its gentrification had eliminated most of the outliers from the airwaves. With the exception of Father Coughlin and a few others, the radio medium had been tamed, with stations and networks alike voluntarily avoiding controversy.
In its 1941 Mayflower decision, the FCC declared that radio stations needed to remain neutral in matters of news and politics, and prohibited them from supporting any particular position or candidate.
In 1949, the commission upped the ante with its implementation of the Fairness Doctrine, which required broadcasters to give equal time to contrasting views on controversial issues. This effectively drove most political debate off the air, except for a few carefully crafted “management editorials.”
The Fairness Doctrine was repealed in 1987, a victim of the new broadcast deregulatory environment. This opened the floodgates and controversy again began to flourish on the country’s airwaves, particularly on today’s popular “hot talk” AM stations.
Although they may not be aware of it, today’s commentators are following on the heels of the pioneer radio provocateurs of the late ’20s and early ’30s, and are thriving in today’s environment of lax regulation and extreme political polarization. Will history repeat itself in some future era with the re-regulation of the media, or has broadcasting been forever changed — for better or worse?