In a decision that could set a precedent as the Federal Communications Commission continues to mull over the local radio ownership caps as part of its quadrennial review, the FCC has granted Draper Media a waiver to exceed ownership caps on the Delmarva Peninsula.
“In this environment, greater scale is essential for radio operators to sustain local service,” the FCC wrote in its Nov. 16 decision, which approved Draper’s $2.5 million acquisition of five stations — four FMs and one AM — and one FM translator from Forever Media.
The commission, in turn, denied a petition to deny the waiver filed by a competing Delaware-based radio owner.
Its decision to approve the waiver included themes we’ve seen referenced by groups that support removing the local radio ownership caps entirely. The Media Bureau said that Salisbury Metro radio revenues have been declining amid competitive pressure from platforms such as Pandora, Spotify, Apple Music, YouTube, podcasts and SiriusXM that were not contemplated when current ownership limits were adopted in 1996.
(Read the commission’s decision.)
The FCC has waived the local ownership rule on several previous occasions, including exceptions granted this year to Sun Broadcasting and Fort Myers Broadcasting to acquire stations in Fort Myers, Fla., from Beasley Media Group, and to Connoisseur Media to acquire stations from Bonneville International in San Francisco.
Radio World had previously reported that Lewes, Del.-based DataTech Digital, which operates the news/talk simulcast of WGMD(FM) in Rehoboth Beach, Del., and WUSX(FM) in Seaford, Del., petitioned the FCC to reject the waiver.
“We find that a waiver of the local radio ownership rule is warranted in this case because the unique characteristics of the Salisbury metro, combined with the specific operational and competitive dynamics presented in the record, demonstrate that strict application of the rule would not serve the public interest,” the Media Bureau wrote.
Station particulars
Draper originally made its case to the commission in July. The company operates 13 commercial FM stations and one commercial AM station stretching from Wilmington, Del., in the north to Salisbury, Md., in the south, including four FM stations within the Salisbury-Ocean City Nielsen Metro.
Two of the stations Draper is acquiring, WXDE(FM) in Lewes, Del., and WAVD(FM) in Ocean Pines, Md., sit inside the Salisbury Metro. The other three full-service outlets, WAFL(FM), WNCL(AM) and WCHK(FM), are licensed to Milford, Del., a city divided between Sussex County inside the Salisbury Metro and Kent County, which is not part of any Nielsen Metro.
Under FCC policy established in 2002, stations licensed to communities straddling a metro boundary count toward that market’s ownership limits.
As a result, closing the Forever Media deal will give Draper nine full-service radio stations in the Salisbury Metro (two above the seven-station cap), including eight FM stations (four above the FM subcap).
DataTech Digital argued the deal would create an effective duopoly, stating that Draper’s market revenue share would climb from 21.6% to 32.9% and its audience share from 21.7% to 30.9%, leaving Draper and market leader iHeartMedia with approximately 67% of market revenue and nearly 75% of reported audience share.
But in response, Draper and Forever argued that the Milford stations generate negligible listenership and revenue within the Salisbury Metro and that greater operational scale would allow Draper to reinvest in local programming and compete more effectively against iHeartMedia.
The Media Bureau sided with the two companies wishing to complete the deal, concluding that strict enforcement of the ownership limits would undermine rather than advance the public interest.
The bureau pointed to Draper’s track record of expanding local news, weather, traffic, emergency information and public-affairs programming following prior acquisitions across Delmarva.
It also said that across the Salisbury Metro’s 40 full-service commercial and noncommercial stations, iHeartMedia will remain the largest operator by both revenue and audience share, at least 16 independent ownership groups will remain active and no reduction in distinct programming formats is expected.
“The resulting strengthening of a locally-based broadcaster in a small and economically constrained market is likely to support more sustainable competition rather than diminish it,” the Media Bureau wrote.
[Do you receive the Radio World SmartBrief newsletter each weekday morning? We invite you to sign up here.]